Industry reports · Humanity Labs

Industry report

Property firms build their own AI while home sales sit near a 30-year low

A briefing on US residential and commercial brokerage, property management, home remodeling, and property security for anyone about to meet the people who run them.

As of October 15, 2026 · Companion to The Originals

Americans bought existing homes at a pace of 3.99 million a year in September 2026, close to the lowest since 1995, and the 30-year mortgage rate went back above 7% in October. NAR Real Estate News Six leaders on our list, from a family brokerage in Pittsburgh to a bathroom remodeler in central Pennsylvania, are answering by building their own AI, taking control of their listings and customers, and running the work from central hubs.

The short version

  • Five businesses earn money in five ways. Brokers take a share of the sale price, managers a share of rent, remodelers a project price, and security firms an hourly rate per guard. More
  • Home sales are stuck near 4 million a year. Mortgage rates went back above 7% in October 2026, and Realtor numbers have fallen far less than sales. More
  • Five changes mark the innovators: building their own AI, taking back the listing and the customer, running the work from one hub, consolidating, and pricing under legal pressure. More
  • Six leaders on our list have made these changes, and three more outside it are making similar moves. Each profile ends with a question to ask. More
  • Portals, referral networks, and lead sellers take a cut. Zillow and the multiple listing services (MLSs) are fighting over who controls a listing. More
  • The work they've rebuilt makes a better opening question than whether AI will replace agents or guards. Saying the settlement crushed commissions, or calling agents employees, marks an outsider. More

How the business works

Five property businesses earn money in five different ways

Outsiders lump these businesses together as "real estate", but each one gets paid by a different customer in a different way. Brokers earn a share of a sale price, property managers a share of rent, remodelers a project price, and security firms an hourly rate for each guard.

The leaders on our list run firms in all five. Each row below is one business; the same question about margin, growth, or headcount means something different in each.

BusinessHow it earnsWho paysTypical priceLargest playersOur leaders
Residential brokerageA commission on the sale price, split between the brokerage and the agent, who is usually an independent contractorUsually the seller; since August 2024 the buyer's agent signs a written agreement with the buyer, and the seller often still paysBuyer's agents averaged 2.42% of the price in late 2025, about where they were before the settlement HousingWireCompass (now with Anywhere), eXp, and HomeServices of America; independent firms hold 28.79% of top-firm volume HousingWireHoby Hanna (Howard Hanna), Ryan Serhant (SERHANT.)
Commercial brokerageCommissions on investment sales and leases, plus fees for arranging financingUsually the seller or landlordNegotiated deal by deal; no published benchmarkCBRE, JLL, and Cushman & Wakefield, whose outsourcing work dwarfs their brokerageKyle Matthews (Matthews)
Property managementA monthly fee set as a share of the rent collected, plus leasing, renewal, and maintenance feesThe building's owner; renters pay some feesVaries by contract and size; not publishedGreystar, the first manager past 1 million apartments; the top 50 manage 23.7% of US apartments MMGJessica Beck (Alfred / Arqline)
Home remodelingA fixed project price, often sold in the home in one visit and often financedThe homeownerWest Shore Home did 80,300 jobs on $1.41 billion of revenue in 2025, about $17,600 each (our arithmetic) Qualified RemodelerLeaf Home, Belfor, and Power Home Remodeling; the top 500 take about 5% of a $519 billion market Qualified RemodelerB.J. Werzyn (West Shore Home)
Security servicesAn hourly bill rate for each guard on site, plus fees for camera monitoringThe property owner or managerBill rates aren't published; guards' median pay is under $19 an hour UC Berkeley Labor CenterAllied Universal, Securitas, and GardaWorldDave Forystek (Premier Security Solutions)

Revenue models differ, so the firms report size differently: agents and sales volume in brokerage, apartments in management, jobs and revenue in remodeling, and guards in security.

Most brokerage agents aren't employees

A brokerage's agents are mostly independent contractors who choose their firm and can leave with their clients. The National Association of Realtors (NAR) counted 1,438,569 members in mid-2026. NAR The typical agent closed nine deals in 2025 and earned $59,200 before expenses. HousingWire So a brokerage headcount like "13,000 agents" says how many people work under the brand, not how many are on the payroll. Remodelers and security firms are the opposite: West Shore Home's installers are on its payroll. Fortune

Big consolidators set the pace for family firms

Compass closed its purchase of Anywhere Real Estate, owner of Coldwell Banker and Century 21, on January 9, 2026. Real Estate News Allied Universal bought eight security companies with about $205 million in yearly revenue between spring and September 2026. Security Today Greystar manages more than 1 million US apartments. Greystar Each of our leaders runs a firm that has chosen to stay independent of these giants.

The economics in 2026

Mortgage rates above 7% keep home sales stuck near 4 million a year

3.99Mexisting homes sold at the September 2026 annual pace source
1.44MNAR members in mid-2026, down from about 1.6 million in 2022 source
$519Bhomeowner remodeling spending projected for mid-2027, growing 0.5% a year source
89%yearly turnover among security guards in 2024 source

Notable change

Rates climb back above 7% as sales start to recover

Existing-home sales rose 1.5% in September 2026 to a 3.99 million annual pace, but they were still 2.2% below a year earlier. The median price reached $417,500. NAR In 2025, sales totaled 4.06 million, matching the lowest level since 1995. NAHB Eye on Housing

Then the 30-year mortgage rate went back above 7% in October. Real Estate News Shower stall, kit, and enclosure sales at Home Depot and Lowe's fell 21% in the year to August 2026, as high rates kept owners from borrowing against their homes. CNBC

So what: All five businesses wait on the mortgage rate. Ask a leader what their plan looks like if rates stay above 7% through 2027.

Home sales moved opposite to mortgage rates through and after the pandemic, and Realtor membership fell far less than sales did.

Home sales fell 44% from their pandemic peak as mortgage rates more than doubled

So what: Brokerage revenue follows sales volume, and volume has sat near 4 million homes a year for three years while rates stayed above 6%. Remodelers feel the same squeeze: owners who won't move also can't easily borrow against their homes. Ask a leader what they've changed to make money in a market this slow, and what they'd do differently if rates fell.

Existing-home sales, seasonally adjusted annual rate (top panel)30-year fixed mortgage rate, quarterly average (bottom panel)
US existing-home sales and the 30-year mortgage rate by quarter, 2019-Q1 to 2026-Q3Pandemic3M4M5M6M7M2%4%6%8%20192020202120222023202420252026Peak 6.77MLow 3.80MLow 2.76%High 7.30%Sales 4.01MRate 6.68%
Existing-home sales are the National Association of Realtors' (NAR) seasonally adjusted annual rate as first published each month, averaged across each quarter's three months; NAR has since revised some months by a few hundredths. Old NAR releases are linked through the Internet Archive because NAR no longer hosts them. The mortgage rate is Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average, from the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED), averaged across the weeks in each quarter. Hover for each quarter; click or tap for details.
Show as a table
QuarterExisting-home sales (annual rate)30-year mortgage rate
2019-Q15.22M (month 1 month 2 month 3)4.37%
2019-Q25.27M (month 1 month 2 month 3)4.01%
2019-Q35.43M (month 1 month 2 month 3)3.66%
2019-Q45.45M (month 1 month 2 month 3)3.70%
2020-Q15.50M (month 1 month 2 month 3)3.52%
2020-Q24.32M (month 1 month 2 month 3)3.24%
2020-Q36.13M (month 1 month 2 month 3)2.95%
2020-Q46.77M (month 1 month 2 month 3)2.76%
2021-Q16.31M (month 1 month 2 month 3)2.88%
2021-Q25.84M (month 1 month 2 month 3)3.00%
2021-Q36.05M (month 1 month 2 month 3)2.87%
2021-Q46.33M (month 1 month 2 month 3)3.08%
2022-Q16.10M (month 1 month 2 month 3)3.82%
2022-Q25.38M (month 1 month 2 month 3)5.27%
2022-Q34.77M (month 1 month 2 month 3)5.62%
2022-Q44.18M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.66%
2023-Q14.34M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.37%
2023-Q24.25M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.51%
2023-Q34.02M (month 1 month 2 month 3)7.04%
2023-Q43.80M (month 1 month 2 month 3)7.30%
2024-Q14.19M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.75%
2024-Q24.05M (month 1 month 2 month 3)7.00%
2024-Q33.88M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.51%
2024-Q44.12M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.63%
2025-Q14.12M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.83%
2025-Q23.99M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.79%
2025-Q34.02M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.57%
2025-Q44.19M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.23%
2026-Q13.99M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.11%
2026-Q24.09M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.41%
2026-Q34.01M (month 1 month 2 month 3)6.68%

Realtor membership kept rising until 2022, a year after home sales peaked, so sales per member fell from 4.7 to 2.7

So what: Fewer sales are spread across almost as many agents, so the typical agent closes few deals a year and brokerages fight over the productive ones. That's why leaders like Ryan Serhant and Kyle Matthews pitch their AI tools as a way to make each agent more productive. Ask a leader how many deals their typical agent closes, and what they've built to raise it.

Realtors (NAR members), millions

0.0M0.5M1.0M1.5M2.0M’122012: 1.00 million1.00M2013: 1.04 million’142014: 1.10 million2015: 1.17 million’162016: 1.23 millionn/a’182018: 1.36 million2019: 1.40 million’202020: 1.46 million2021: 1.56 million’222022: 1.58 million1.58M2023: 1.55 million’242024: 1.50 million’252025: 1.49 million1.49M

Existing-home sales, millions

0M1M2M3M4M5M6M7M’122012: 4.67 million4.67M2013: 5.09 million’142014: 4.93 million2015: 5.26 million’162016: 5.45 million2017: 5.51 million’182018: 5.34 millionn/a’202020: 5.64 million2021: 6.12 million6.12M’222022: 5.03 million2023: 4.09 million’242024: 4.06 million’252025: 4.06 million4.06M
NAR membership counts the agents and brokers who belong to NAR, not every licensee. NAR stopped publishing regular counts in 2024, so the 2024 figure is the count at the start of January 2025 and the 2025 figure is as of September 30, 2025; 2017 membership and 2019 sales are n/a because we found no verified figure. Existing-home sales are NAR's calendar-year totals as first reported. Sales per member was 4.7 in 2012 and 2.7 in 2025. Sources are in the table.
Show as a table
YearNAR membersExisting-home salesSales per member
20121.00M4.67M4.7
20131.04M5.09M4.9
20141.10M4.93M4.5
20151.17M5.26M4.5
20161.23M5.45M4.4
2017n/a5.51Mn/a
20181.36M5.34M3.9
20191.40Mn/an/a
20201.46M5.64M3.9
20211.56M6.12M3.9
20221.58M5.03M3.2
20231.55M4.09M2.6
20241.50M4.06M2.7
20251.49M4.06M2.7

Three more pressures sit under the numbers:

  • Apartment owners give away rent to fill buildings. In August 2026, 15.4% of stabilized apartments offered concessions, averaging about 11% of rent, while occupancy held at 95.5%. RealPage Insurance per apartment rose from $502 in 2021 to $777 in 2024. NAA
  • Commercial deals are back, but mostly for data centers. Data centers drove the rise in commercial deal volume in the second quarter of 2026, The Real Deal while 12.16% of office loans in commercial mortgage bonds were delinquent in September. Trepp via Yieldpro
  • Tariffs and turnover raise costs for remodelers and guard firms. The 25% tariff on kitchen cabinets and vanities is set to double to 50% on January 1, 2027. NAHB Security guard turnover reached 89% in 2024, against 66% across the private sector. UC Berkeley Labor Center

What is changing

Property firms are changing how the work gets done in five ways

The firms changing most are deciding what to own instead of rent: their software, their listings, and their operations. In multifamily, 89% of operators say they use AI, but only 14% have fully automated leasing from first inquiry to signed lease, according to a survey by EliseAI, a company that sells AI leasing agents. EliseAI

From 2023 to 2026, the changes fall into five themes. The first three match the three groups of leaders on our list, and each cuts across brokerage, management, remodeling, and security.

1. Building their own AI

A few firms build their own software so their methods don't become a vendor's product sold to rivals. SERHANT. raised $45 million in December 2024 partly to build its S.MPLE platform and released S.MPLE 2.0 to its agents in 2026. HousingWire Matthews says its engineering team grew 220% from 2022 to mid-2026 to build Artemis, its own AI client database. Matthews West Shore Home bought a software firm in 2022 and built its own room-scanning app. West Shore Home

On our list: Ryan Serhant, Kyle Matthews, B.J. Werzyn.

2. Taking back the listing and the customer

Brokerages are deciding who sees a listing first: their own agents, the multiple listing service (MLS), or the portals. Office exclusives reached nearly 8% of new listings in the Bright MLS region by February 2025. BAM Howard Hanna launched its own private listing network, HannaList, in 2026, Real Estate News and Zillow and Realtor.com now share revenue with listing agents who give them homes before the MLS. RISMedia

On our list: Hoby Hanna.

3. Running the work from one central hub

Apartment managers are moving collections, renewals, and paperwork out of each building into central teams. In April 2023, Gables Residential moved conversations about unpaid rent and late fees to an outside call center, and Fogelman Properties created specialists who each handle accounting for four or five properties. Multifamily Executive Security firms are doing the same with remote camera monitoring: GardaWorld bought Stealth Monitoring, which had about 1,100 full-time operators in six monitoring centers. SDM

On our list: Jessica Beck, Dave Forystek.

4. Consolidating into giants

Compass bought Anywhere, Allied Universal keeps buying regional guard firms, and Greystar passed 1 million apartments under management. Real Estate News Security Today Greystar An Anywhere shareholder sued in October 2026, claiming "backchanneling" helped the Compass deal close. The Real Deal

5. Pricing and fees under legal pressure

The Justice Department has settled with five landlords over rent-setting software from RealPage; Camden hasn't settled. Multifamily Dive Greystar agreed to pay $24 million to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Colorado over fees left out of advertised rents. HousingWire Zillow and Redfin settled an FTC case over their rental listings deal in August 2026. Multifamily Dive

The innovators

Six leaders on our list are rebuilding how their property firms work

Six leaders in these businesses are among The Originals. Each has made a dated, costly change to how the work is done. The highest scorers are B.J. Werzyn of West Shore Home (7.5), Hoby Hanna of Howard Hanna (7.1), and Ryan Serhant of SERHANT. (6.0).

15 of these 19 dated moves came in 2023 or later

So what: Most of these leaders made their costliest moves after mortgage rates jumped in 2022, when sales fell and every deal or job had to earn more. The changes are recent, so asking what has paid off, and what they'd undo, is a natural way to open a conversation.

Building their own AITaking back the listing and the customerRunning the work from one central hub
Dated moves by 6 leaders on our list, 2019 to 2026Pandemic20192020202120222023202420252026Hoby HannaHoby Hanna, 2022: Merges with HER Realtors in Columbus, OhioHoby Hanna, 2023: Pulls Cleveland listings from rivals' websitesHoby Hanna, 2025: Tells NAR its Clear Cooperation Policy isn't bindingHoby Hanna, 2025: Buys Elegran, its first New York City firmKyle MatthewsKyle Matthews, 2022: Moves headquarters to Nashville and names a tech hubKyle Matthews, 2025: Rebrands around its own technology platformKyle Matthews, 2026: Builds Artemis after growing engineering 220%Jessica BeckJessica Beck, 2022: Buys RKW Residential, a manager of about 30,000 apartmentsJessica Beck, 2025: Merges with Lennar's Quarterra LivingJessica Beck, 2026: Launches Arqline to run both firms as oneB.J. WerzynB.J. Werzyn, 2022: Buys a software firm to build tools in-houseB.J. Werzyn, 2023: Launches Hawkeye, a 3D room-scanning appB.J. Werzyn, 2024: Hires a chief data and AI officerB.J. Werzyn, 2026: Hires a CTO to unify scanning, scheduling, and AIDave ForystekDave Forystek, 2023: Buys offices for a live remote-monitoring command centerDave Forystek, 2023: Expands guards and monitoring across statesRyan SerhantRyan Serhant, 2024: Raises $45 million to build his firm's own AIRyan Serhant, 2026: Releases S.MPLE 2.0 with an AI chief of staffRyan Serhant, 2026: Opens in Chicago
Each dot is one costly change to how the work is done. Click a dot for a short summary and a link to the story.
Show as a table
YearLeaderMoveSource
2022B.J. WerzynBuys a software firm to build tools in-houseWest Shore Home
2022Hoby HannaMerges with HER Realtors in Columbus, OhioRISMedia
2022Jessica BeckBuys RKW Residential, a manager of about 30,000 apartmentsMultifamily Dive
2022Kyle MatthewsMoves headquarters to Nashville and names a tech hubMatthews
2023B.J. WerzynLaunches Hawkeye, a 3D room-scanning appWest Shore Home
2023Dave ForystekBuys offices for a live remote-monitoring command centerABC12
2023Dave ForystekExpands guards and monitoring across statesABC12
2023Hoby HannaPulls Cleveland listings from rivals' websitesReal Estate News
2024B.J. WerzynHires a chief data and AI officerWest Shore Home
2024Ryan SerhantRaises $45 million to build his firm's own AICommercial Observer
2025Hoby HannaTells NAR its Clear Cooperation Policy isn't bindingRISMedia
2025Hoby HannaBuys Elegran, its first New York City firmReal Estate News
2025Jessica BeckMerges with Lennar's Quarterra LivingMultifamily Dive
2025Kyle MatthewsRebrands around its own technology platformMatthews
2026B.J. WerzynHires a CTO to unify scanning, scheduling, and AICIO Dive
2026Jessica BeckLaunches Arqline to run both firms as oneMultifamily Executive
2026Kyle MatthewsBuilds Artemis after growing engineering 220%Matthews
2026Ryan SerhantReleases S.MPLE 2.0 with an AI chief of staffHousingWire
2026Ryan SerhantOpens in ChicagoChicago Sun-Times

Building their own AI

Ryan Serhant
Ryan SerhantOn the list · 6.0 of 10
Founder and CEO, SERHANT. · New York; brokerage he founded in 2020, with more than 2,000 agents and 200 full-time staff, the firm says

Ryan raised $45 million in December 2024, led by Camber Creek, to build S.MPLE, his firm's own AI platform. Commercial Observer In September 2026 he released S.MPLE 2.0, which handles listing preparation, marketing, and transaction paperwork through an AI "chief of staff" called Dot, and kept it inside the brokerage rather than selling it. HousingWire The firm opened in Chicago in October 2026. Chicago Sun-Times

“Chatbots give you answers, but S.MPLE 2.0 gives you outcomes.” source

Ask aboutWhich part of an agent's week S.MPLE has taken over, and what his agents do with the time.

Kyle Matthews
Kyle MatthewsOn the list · 5.9 of 10
Founder and CEO, Matthews · Nashville; commercial brokerage he founded in 2015, with more than 1,000 agents and employees in 30+ offices

Kyle moved Matthews' headquarters from El Segundo, California, to Nashville in 2022 and named Phoenix its operations and technology hub. Matthews Matthews says its engineering division grew 220% from 2022 to mid-2026 to build Artemis, its own AI client database, and in January 2026 he said the firm was tuning its own AI models. Matthews Matthews

“We're taking a multi-pronged approach, and we are laying the foundation internally to hyper-tune models for strategic areas that we hope to dominate in.” source

Ask aboutWhich broker tasks Artemis has taken over, and why he chose to hire engineers in-house instead of buying software.

B.J. Werzyn
B.J. WerzynOn the list · 7.5 of 10
Founder and CEO, West Shore Home · Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania; bath, shower, and window remodeler he founded in 2006, with more than 3,200 employees, including its installers; Leonard Green has owned 20% since 2020

B.J. bought a St. Paul software firm in 2022 and turned it into the team that built Hawkeye, an iPhone app that scans a room in 3D in under a minute, launched in October 2023. West Shore Home West Shore Home He hired a chief data and AI officer in 2024 and a chief technology officer in August 2026. CIO Dive Fortune reports he plans to double revenue to about $2 billion with about 6,000 employees instead of 7,000. Fortune

“Nobody's going to replace the last mile of a home remodeling project,” source

Ask aboutWhich jobs at West Shore Home AI changes, and which ones he'd never hand to it.

Taking back the listing and the customer

Hoby Hanna
Hoby HannaOn the list · 7.1 of 10
CEO, Howard Hanna Real Estate Services · Pittsburgh; the largest family-owned US brokerage, third generation, with more than 500 offices and about 15,000 agents and staff

Hoby became CEO in 2023 and within weeks pulled Howard Hanna's Cleveland-area listings out of the shared feed that lets rival brokers' websites show them, so buyers see them on Howard Hanna's own site. Real Estate News In May 2025 he told NAR and the MLSs that Hanna Holdings doesn't consider NAR's Clear Cooperation Policy binding. RISMedia In 2026 the firm launched HannaList, its own pre-market listing network. Real Estate News

“We know so many of you go out and get a hard-earned listing and that gets marketed and scraped by so many different people as opposed to yourself.” source

Ask aboutWhat happened to in-house deals in Cleveland after the switch, and why he's chosen a middle path on pre-marketing rather than following Compass.

Running the work from one central hub

Jessica Beck
Jessica BeckOn the list · 3.8 of 10
Co-founder and CEO, Alfred / Arqline · New York; Alfred, the company she co-founded in 2014, now runs about 50,000 apartments in 31 markets under the Arqline name

Jessica turned a property technology company into a property manager. Alfred bought RKW Residential, with about 30,000 apartments, in 2022, Multifamily Dive merged with Lennar's Quarterra Living in June 2025, Multifamily Dive and in March 2026 launched Arqline to run both under one centralized, AI-supported operating model. Multifamily Executive

“We are engineering a platform where technology and artificial intelligence (AI) work alongside our people, not in place of them, to eliminate the noise, amplify insight, and elevate performance across every asset.” source

Ask aboutWhich jobs moved from the buildings to the central team when the three companies combined, and what residents noticed.

Dave Forystek
Dave ForystekOn the list · 3.8 of 10
Founder, Premier Security Solutions · Burton, Michigan; guard and monitoring company he founded in 2013 as a retired Flint police officer, with more than 1,200 guards in 2023; the company says it has since been acquired by Alpha Video Surveillance

Dave bought former credit union offices in Burton in 2023 to build a command center that watches client sites live, backed by a fleet of solar-powered camera trailers. ABC12 The company later flew autonomous drones from docks at client sites, monitored from that center. FlytBase Premier's leadership page now says it was "recently acquired" by Alpha Video Surveillance and runs under a shared leadership structure. Premier Security Solutions

“It's more than just reactionary and going back and looking at what happened. We're watching it in real time and stopping it from happening in many cases.” source

Ask aboutWhat role he plays now that Premier is part of Alpha Video Surveillance, and how the command center changed what a guard does on site.

Three leaders outside the list are making similar moves

These leaders aren't on the list. Each runs a family-controlled firm and has made a change worth asking about.

Steve Baird
President and CEO, Baird & Warner · Chicago; sixth-generation family-owned brokerage founded in 1855, with nearly 3,000 agents, loan officers, and staff after merging with Dream Town in 2025

Steve merged Baird & Warner with Dream Town in June 2025; Dream Town's founder said every other major Chicago brokerage was "run by Wall Street or a hedge fund". HousingWire In May 2026 he put brokerage, mortgage, and title under one chief revenue officer, and said ownership "remains unchanged and in family hands". HousingWire

“We are not thinking in terms of quarters, but generations.” source

Ask aboutWhat one revenue leader over brokerage, mortgage, and title changes for an agent and a client.

Brian Duffy
CEO, Per Mar Security Services · Davenport, Iowa; family-owned security company in its third generation, with more than 2,800 people across 25 branches

Brian runs one of the few family-owned Midwest security firms that sells guards, alarms, and live video monitoring together, the mix that national buyers such as GardaWorld are paying for. Security Systems News

Ask aboutWhich clients are swapping guard hours for monitored cameras, and what that does to the guards he keeps.

Jonathan and Jason Morgan
Co-CEOs, Morgan Properties · King of Prussia, Pennsylvania; family-founded apartment owner and manager with more than 2,500 employees

Jonathan and Jason, co-CEOs since early 2026, rolled one leasing customer relationship management (CRM) system across the whole portfolio in 2025 Funnel and hired the firm's first head of technology in April 2026 to replace scattered AI use with a company-wide program. Bisnow

Ask aboutWhat the new head of technology was hired to change first, and which on-site jobs it touches.

The wider field

Public giants and AI vendors set the terms the family firms react to

A few large firms and vendors shape what the leaders above can do. They set the price of a listing, an acquisition, and the software everyone else rents.

Large firms and buyers

  • Compass The largest US brokerage after buying Anywhere; reported 83,184 agents at its own brokerages in mid-2026.
  • Greystar The largest US property manager, past 1 million apartments; paid $24 million to settle the FTC's fee case.
  • Allied Universal The largest security company, owned by private equity; bought eight firms in 2026.
  • GardaWorld Bought Stealth Monitoring to lead remote, AI-assisted video guarding.

Companies selling the tools

  • EliseAI AI agents for apartment leasing, renewals, and collections; publishes the operator survey cited above.
  • RealPage Rent-setting and property software at the center of the Justice Department's pricing case.
  • FlytBase Software for autonomous security drones, used by Premier Security Solutions.

How customers find the firms

Portals, referral networks, and lead sellers take a share of each customer

Notable change

Zillow and the MLSs are fighting over who controls a listing

Compass lost its bid in February 2026 to stop Zillow's ban on homes marketed privately before the MLS, then dropped its lawsuit in March after Zillow accepted some pre-marketing. Real Estate News Real Estate News In May, Chicago's MLS cut Zillow's listing feeds, and a judge ordered them restored. HousingWire

NAR says its Clear Cooperation Policy, which requires a listing to reach the MLS within a business day of public marketing, "is still applicable when you talk about pre-marketing and office exclusives". Real Estate News Zillow and Realtor.com now pay listing agents a share of revenue for homes shown on their portals before the MLS. RISMedia

So what: Zillow and Realtor.com now pay for some of a brokerage's listings, which brokerages used to treat as a cost of doing business. Ask a leader who sees their listings first, and what they've been offered for them.

Each business pays a different middleman. Agents pay Zillow and referral networks a share of their commission when a lead closes. Brokers pay relocation companies for corporate moves. Apartment managers pay listing sites every month, and remodelers buy leads from Angi and Thumbtack whether or not they win the job. A customer referred by a past client costs nothing.

75%+of Zillow's buyer connections it plans to route through its pay-at-closing Preferred program by the end of 2026, up from 44% a year earlier source
33%of an agent's commission paid to HomeLight when one of its referrals closes source
34,000agents paying for Homes.com memberships in April 2026 source
13%drop in leads Angi sold to contractors in the second quarter of 2026 source

These firms pay five of the seven channels that bring them customers

So what: Agents give portals and referral networks a share of each commission, apartment managers pay listing sites every month, and remodelers pay for leads they may never win. Only a past client's referral and a firm's own listings cost nothing. Ask a leader what share of the business comes through channels they pay, and what they've built to win customers directly.

The firm or its agent pays the channelNo fee to the channel

Fee levels come from company filings, trade press, and a consumer group's study; most portals and referral networks don't publish rate cards. Each links to its source.
Show as a table
ChannelExamplesDoes the firm pay?What it costs the firmSource
Home search portalsZillow, Realtor.com, Homes.comYesZillow's pay-at-closing fee is most often reported at 35% of the agent's commissionThe Close
Referral networksHomeLight, Redfin partner agentsYesHomeLight takes 33% of the agent's commissionInman
Relocation companiesCartus, SIRVAYesReferral fees mostly run 20-35% of the commissionConsumer Federation of America
Past clients and referralsFriends, family, and repeat customersNoNo fee; 43% of buyers found their agent by referral and 18% reused an agentVirginia REALTORS
The firm's own listings and siteHannaList, office exclusives, brokerage websitesNoNo fee to a middleman; office exclusives reached nearly 8% of new listings in one large MLSBAM
Apartment listing sitesApartments.com, Zillow RentalsYesA monthly package fee per property; prices aren't publishedMultifamily Dive
Home-improvement lead sellersAngi, HomeAdvisor, ThumbtackYesPaid per lead, won or not; Angi's leads fell 13% in mid-2026MarketBeat

A few owners control the channels

  • Zillow Group The largest home search portal; also runs StreetEasy and rental listings.
  • CoStar Group Owns Homes.com, Apartments.com, and LoopNet, the main commercial listing site.
  • News Corp Owns Realtor.com through Move, Inc.
  • Compass Owns the Cartus relocation business since buying Anywhere in January 2026.
  • Rocket Companies Owns Redfin, which must restart selling apartment ads under the August 2026 FTC settlement.

What it means for the firms

  • A portal customer now costs a share of the commission. Zillow's pay-at-closing fee is most often reported at 35% of the agent's side, up to 40% in some markets. The Close Relocation companies' referral fees mostly run 20-35%, a consumer group found. Consumer Federation of America
  • Repeat and referred customers are the cheapest. In NAR's 2025 survey, 43% of buyers found their agent through a referral, and 18% used an agent they'd worked with before. Virginia REALTORS Brokerages that keep past clients pay no middleman.
  • Remodelers pay for leads they don't win. The FTC ordered HomeAdvisor to pay up to $7.2 million in 2023 over the quality of the leads it sold. TechCrunch The median remodeler on the Top 500 list spent $372 per lead that turned into a sales appointment. Qualified Remodeler

Rules for the middlemen are changing

WhenWhoWhat it does
Jan 2023FTCOrdered HomeAdvisor to pay up to $7.2 million over misleading claims about its leads. TechCrunch
Aug 2024NAR settlementBuyers sign written agreements with their agents, and offers to pay buyer's agents are banned from the MLS. HousingWire
Feb 2026Federal courtRefused to block Zillow's ban on privately marketed listings. Real Estate News
May 2026Federal courtOrdered Chicago's MLS to restore Zillow's listing feeds. HousingWire
Aug 2026FTCSettled with Zillow and Redfin over their rental listings deal; Redfin must sell apartment ads again. Multifamily Dive
In forceFTCGives buyers three days to cancel most sales made in their home, the rule behind in-home remodeling sales. eCFR

Four leaders run the main channels

Jeremy Wacksman runs Zillow and Andy Florance runs CoStar, owner of Homes.com and Apartments.com. Damian Eales runs Realtor.com, and Mike Steib took over Angi, the largest seller of home-improvement leads, in September 2026.

Jeremy Wacksman
Jeremy Wacksman
CEO, Zillow Group · Seattle; the largest home search portal, public

Jeremy is moving Zillow from selling ads to agents toward a pay-at-closing referral program, Zillow Preferred. Zillow plans to use Preferred for more than 75% of its buyer connections by the end of 2026, up from 44% at the end of 2025. Zillow In 2026 he also launched Zillow Preview, a pre-market listing program that pays listing agents a share of revenue. RISMedia

“AI can be used for great things, but it could also be used to misrepresent what a house looks like or what a listing photo looks like.” source

Ask aboutOnce most buyer leads run through Preferred, what share of a partner agent's commission goes to Zillow.

Andy Florance
Andy Florance
Founder and CEO, CoStar Group (Homes.com, Apartments.com, LoopNet) · Owns the main commercial, apartment, and Homes.com listing sites; public

Andy built Homes.com on the promise that a listing's buyer goes to the listing agent; subscribers rose to 34,000 by April 2026. Real Estate News Under investor pressure, CoStar is cutting Homes.com spending by about 35% in 2026. HousingWire

“So we actually have a glut of rentals and a shortage of homes.” source

Ask aboutWhether Homes.com will keep its promise not to sell a listing's buyers to other agents as spending falls.

Damian Eales
Damian Eales
CEO, Move, Inc. (Realtor.com) · Realtor.com's operator, owned by News Corp; CEO since 2023

Damian grew Realtor.com's revenue to $610 million in the year to June 2026 and agreed in May 2026 to show Zillow's Preview listings, sharing revenue with listing agents. HousingWire RISMedia

“We've long said that an open marketplace – one built around transparency and broad access – is what's best for consumers and the industry, and last quarter we backed that up with action,” source

Ask aboutWhether Realtor.com is now Zillow's partner or its competitor, and what that means for brokerages that pay both.

Mike Steib
Mike Steib
CEO, Angi Inc. (Angi, HomeAdvisor) · Denver; the largest home services lead marketplace, public since IAC spun it off in 2025; CEO since September 22, 2026

Mike took over from Jeff Kip on September 22, 2026, after a quarter in which Angi's revenue fell 11% and its leads fell 13%. Executive Moves MarketBeat

Ask aboutWhether Angi will share each homeowner request with fewer contractors, or charge more for each lead.

Trade-offs

Six trade-offs divide the leaders you'll meet

Most leaders on our list have picked a side on several of these. In our reading, asking which side they picked, and why, gets to their strategy faster than asking about trends.

1Build your own AI or buy it

SERHANT. raised $45 million partly to build its own AI platform. Commercial Observer

Most apartment managers buy AI from vendors; only 14% have fully automated leasing. EliseAI

AskWhich AI tool would you never rent from a vendor, because it's how you beat your rivals?

2Keep a listing in-house or send it everywhere

Howard Hanna pulled its Cleveland listings from rivals' websites and built its own private network. Real Estate News Real Estate News

90% of office exclusives in the Bright MLS region still reached the MLS before going under contract. BAM

AskWho should see a seller's home first, and who decides: the seller, the agent, or the firm?

3Agents as contractors or employees

Most brokerage agents are independent contractors who pay their own costs. HousingWire

West Shore Home keeps its installers on the payroll. Fortune

AskWhat can you ask of people you employ that you can't ask of contractors?

4Staff each building or run it from a hub

Arqline runs about 50,000 apartments under one centralized operating model. Multifamily Executive

Fogelman Properties kept its existing technology and gave specialists four or five properties each. Multifamily Executive

AskWhich work has to happen in the building, and which can happen anywhere?

5Guards on site or cameras watched remotely

Premier Security Solutions built a command center to watch client sites live. ABC12

Guard turnover runs at 89% a year, so every guard post has to be refilled about once a year. UC Berkeley Labor Center

AskWhen a client cuts guard hours for cameras, what happens to the guards you keep?

6Sell to a consolidator or stay family-owned

Compass bought Anywhere, and Allied Universal bought eight security firms in 2026. Real Estate News Security Today

Baird & Warner's CEO says ownership "remains unchanged and in family hands". HousingWire

AskIf a buyer offered a record price tomorrow, what would your family have to believe to say no?

Before a first conversation

Leaders want to talk about rates, listing rules, consolidation, and AI

In late 2026, brokerage leaders talk about slow sales, the fight over private listings, and what the Compass and Anywhere merger means for recruiting agents. Apartment managers talk about concessions, insurance, and the RealPage cases. Remodelers talk about tariffs and the cost of leads, and security firms about turnover and remote monitoring.

Seven mistakes mark an outsider

  • Saying the NAR settlement crushed commissions. Buyer's agents averaged 2.42% in late 2025, slightly more than a year earlier. The change is in the paperwork and in who negotiates the fee. HousingWire
  • Calling agents employees. Most are independent contractors who choose their brokerage.
  • Saying Clear Cooperation is dead. It's still NAR policy, and NAR restated it in July 2026. Real Estate News
  • Reading every apartment concession as distress. Occupancy was 95.5% in August 2026, and the share of units offering concessions has fallen. RealPage
  • Assuming people who can't move remodel instead. High rates also block the home equity loans that pay for projects. CNBC
  • Saying cameras will replace guards. Most firms mix the two, so the useful question is what each one does.
  • Using RealPage as shorthand for wrongdoing. The manager you're meeting may be a defendant or a class member.

Eleven questions get these leaders talking about the work

  1. Rates went back above 7% in October. What did you change the last time rates jumped, and what would you do differently now?
  2. (Brokerage) Buyer agreements became mandatory two years ago. How has an agent's first conversation with a buyer changed?
  3. (Brokerage) Where have you landed on office exclusives and pre-marketing, and how do your sellers choose?
  4. (Brokerage) Since Compass bought Anywhere, has recruiting agents gotten easier or harder for you?
  5. Which job in your company has AI changed most so far, and which did you expect to change that hasn't?
  6. (Property management) If you've centralized leasing or renewals, what did the on-site team stop doing, and what did residents notice?
  7. (Property management) Insurance is your fastest-rising cost. What have you changed in how you operate, beyond the costs you pass on?
  8. (Remodeling) Growth in remodeling spending is projected near zero by mid-2027. Are you seeing it in leads or in close rates?
  9. (Remodeling) Cabinet and vanity tariffs may double on January 1. How do you handle the gap between the price you quote and the install date?
  10. (Security) On accounts that moved to cameras and remote monitoring, what happened to the guard's job?
  11. What's one thing you rebuilt in the last two years that you'd do again, and one you'd undo?

Where they gather

Six events bring these leaders together before July 2027

NAR NXT draws residential brokers, the NMHC Annual Meeting and Apartmentalize draw apartment owners and managers, and ICSC draws commercial brokers. KBIS draws remodelers and their suppliers.

Glossary

Twenty-four terms come up in the first ten minutes

Bill rate
The hourly price a security firm charges a client for a guard; the guard's pay is the pay rate, and the gap covers overhead and margin.
Buyer agreement
A written contract, required since August 2024, that sets what a buyer's agent does and how they're paid before the buyer tours homes.
Cap
The yearly amount an agent pays the brokerage, after which the agent keeps all of each commission.
Cap rate
A property's net operating income divided by its price; a lower cap rate means a higher price for each dollar of income.
Centralization
Moving leasing, renewals, and paperwork out of each building into a shared or remote team.
Clear Cooperation Policy
NAR's rule that a listing must go into the MLS within one business day of any public marketing.
Concessions
Discounts such as free weeks of rent used to win leases.
Dual agency
One agent or brokerage representing both buyer and seller in the same deal; some states limit or ban it.
IDX
Internet Data Exchange: the feed and rules that let a brokerage show other brokers' MLS listings on its own website.
In-home sale
A remodeling sales model where a rep measures, presents, and aims to close in one visit to the home.
Lease-up
The period after a new building opens when it fills from empty to stable occupancy.
MLS
Multiple listing service: a local database where member brokers share listings.
NOI
Net operating income: rent and other income minus operating costs, before debt payments.
OM
Offering memorandum: the marketing book a commercial broker prepares to sell an investment property.
Office exclusive
A listing shared only inside one brokerage and kept off the MLS, with the seller's signed consent.
Post orders
The written instructions that tell a guard what to do at a given post.
Pre-marketing
Promoting a listing to a firm's own agents, or on a portal's preview program, before it goes to the MLS.
Referral fee
The share of a commission one agent or company pays another for sending a client.
Relocation management company
A firm, such as Cartus, that runs an employer's moving benefit and assigns transferees to network brokers for a fee.
Remote video monitoring
Off-site operators watching live cameras, often with AI alerts, who warn off intruders or call for help.
Revenue management
Software that recommends daily rents for each apartment.
Split
How a commission divides between the agent and the brokerage, for example 70/30.
Team
A group of agents under a lead agent inside a brokerage, sharing leads and staff.
VOW
Virtual office website: a brokerage site where registered clients can see more MLS data than the public sees.

Read more

Three pieces explain AI, listings, and remodeling in 2026